By John Shaw


John Shaw Nature & Digital Photography Workshops
Click here for locations and dates
Mexico's Colonial Heartland
March 17–24, 2007
Horses and Icons of the Wild West
August 26–September 1, 2007
Masai Mara Wildlife Reserve, Kenya
September 7–21, 2007
Australia Wildlife
November 1–20, 2007
Why in the world would I even think about writing a piece on hand meters? You remember what those things are, totally separate devices about the size of a couple of film boxes put together. What's the point in talking about them? After all, Nikons and Canons have built-in meters with spot, center-weighted, and evaluative matrix metering patterns and wide sensitivity ranges. Why bring up some old style equipment from years ago?

Well, if you work with panoramic or view cameras you'll want — make that "need" — a hand meter. It may come as a shock to some of us raised on 35mm SLRs, but not all cameras have exposure meters built into them. Even if you work exclusively with 35mm, there are times you might consider using a hand meter.




First of all, there are two types of meters, incident and reflective. Here's the difference: incident meters read the light falling on a subject, reflective meters measure the light bouncing off a subject. Used correctly, and interpreted correctly, both kinds of meters will give you accurate results (and indeed if both types are used in the same light, both should give the same exposure values).

Let's start with reflective meters, since everyone is familiar with these and you already own one. This is the meter built into all 35mm SLRs. You point the meter — the camera in this case — at your subject and it gives you an aperture/shutter speed combination. What it doesn't do is give you the correct exposure values for a perfect picture. It might, but it might not. All reflective meters — with two exceptions which I'll mention shortly — do one thing and one thing only: they tell you the values to use to record your subject as a medium tone, regardless of the actual tonality of the subject. Have an average-toned subject, and you can fire away. Work a light or dark subject and you'll need to add or subtract light to that base meter reading. The meter always starts at a middle-tone placement, so you must add light to record a subject as a lighter tone, take light away to record as a darker tone. Here's a widely used chart for the amount of light to add or subtract (in stop increments):

whitish +2

EXTREMELY LIGHT +2

light light +1

LIGHT +1

dark light +

MEDIUM the metered values

light dark -

DARK -1

dark dark - 1

EXTREMELY DARK - 2

blackish - 2

To use this chart, just add the name of a color. For example, to record something as a light blue tone, add one stop of light to the meter reading taken of that particular area and only that area. An additional stop of light would make it record as a light, light blue. Get the idea?

The exceptions to this are the evaluative matrix metering modes on current Canon and Nikon cameras. Both systems use software programs to make a judgment call as to proper exposure, and both systems suggest you never dial in any compensation when using this metering pattern. The reason is simple: you don't know what the software has done so you have no idea how much light you should add or subtract.

Now let's return to my subject of hand meters. The reason I'm writing about hand meters is that a previous column was on panoramic cameras, a format I like to shoot, and I received several questions about metering. My Fuji GX617 pan has no meter whatsoever. In order to determine proper exposure I must do one of two things. Either I carry one of my Nikons, take a meter reading with it and transfer the values to the Fuji, or I use a hand meter. I've done the Nikon bit and it certainly works, but there are times when I want to pack only the pan camera and its lenses and not add any additional 35mm gear.




The most useful reflective hand meter reads only a narrow angle of a few degrees. In fact, the most common reflective meter is the one degree spot meter, which works in exactly the same manner as does the spot meter in Nikons and Canons. A spot meter looks sort of like a child's toy pistol; it has a grip with a lens above it through which you view your subject. You're metering a small, precise area. With your SLR you take the meter reading through any filters you might have on your lens, but not so with a hand meter. The solution is to either use filter factors (yuck, one more thing to worry about), or figure out how much additional light your most used filters require. For example, an 81A needs an additional 1/3 stop of light. An easy way to determine this is to meter the same subject, with and without the filter, and compare the results. The catch-22, though, is when you use a polarizer as its total light loss is somewhere between one and two stops, depending on its orientation to the light. Not to worry; there is a reasonably easy solution. View through the filter while you rotate it for the effect you want. If you're using a circular polarizer make sure the filter threads are towards your face, as circular polarizers are one-directional. Hold the filter in the same position in front of your spot meter, take a meter reading, note the filter's orientation by looking at the brand name lettering on the filter, screw the filter onto the lens so that it's oriented once again in the same direction, and take your picture. That's actually a lot easier to do than to describe.

Remember that you still have to place tonal values. That's the negative side of all reflected light meters. They only tell you how to get middle tone, not how to get correct exposure. Always refer to that tonal chart whenever you're using a reflective meter. The plus of using a spot meter is that you can be standing in different light than your subject but still take a meter reading. For example, imagine you're in bright sun next to a rock face, but you're photographing a pattern on the shaded side of the rocks. No problem. Just meter, place your tonal values, and trip the shutter.

An incident meter works in a different manner. Incident meters have a white hemispheric dome rather than a viewing lens and eyepiece. To take a meter reading you must hold the meter in the same light as your subject and point the dome back at the camera position. You're measuring the light falling on the subject. This is the same thing as taking a reflected light meter reading off a gray card held at the subject position. You take a reading and shoot at the given shutter speed/apertures values unless your subject is at one end or the other of the tonal scale. In other words, if the subject is quite dark you'll need to open up a stop from the indicated reading, or if it's very light you'll need to stop down one stop to hold detail. Seem strange? Think about this: the old "sunny -16" rule places a middle-tone subject as a middle tone on film. But you still have to stop down one stop for white subjects, and open up one stop for black subjects. An incident meter is the equivalent, in any light, of "sunny -16."

The joy of incident meters is that you don't have to worry about subject tonality except for the extremes. Since more things are average than un-average, you can usually just take a meter reading with an incident meter and shoot. But if you're using any filter you've got to allow for it, and there is no way to take a reading through a filter with an incident meter. So here's that bugbear, the polarizer. Add a polarizer to a lens and it's effectively a one-stop ND filter if you see no polarization effect at all. At maximum polarization (right angle to the sun's axis, that is) one additional stop of light is lost. When you use an incident meter you must remember to open up, but how much do you open up when you're using a polarizer to determine the glare off wet leaves on an overcast day? One stop? One and a half?

For 35mm shooters there are a couple of situations where a separate meter is "handy," so to speak. When you're working on landscapes, at times you might not want to change your composition to take a meter reading. A spot meter could be useful here. If you're working animals with a long lens, and you're in the same light as the critters, then taking an incident reading with the meter pointed back over your shoulder is a quick way to get correct exposure. I often check



my exposures this way on African safaris by holding my meter out the side of the safari vehicle opposite the animal. Better to double check the light than discover an exposure mistake when you look at the film back home.

There are a number of good meters on the market. Pentax, Gossen, Sekonic, and Minolta are the major brands, and I would stick with one of these. The digital models are far more rugged than the older style with swinging needle. Some models I have used and recommend are:

  • The Pentax 1 Digital, a solidly made one-degree spot meter that reads out in 1/3 stops.

  • Sekonic 318 Digi Light incident meter (or the 328F Digi Light which incorporates a flash meter); both give readings in 1/10 stop. The 318 is the hand meter that Joe Van Os always carries.





  • The Gossen Luna Star F2, my favorite digital incident meter (which also measures flash output). Displays in 1/10 f-stop.

  • The Sekonic L-508 Zoom Master. A unique hand meter, it combines an incident meter, a variable 1 - 4 degree spot meter, and a flash meter into one unit. It offers a 1/10 stop readout. When I'm working with my panoramic camera, this has become my standard meter.


Questions and Answers

John Shaw will answer readers' questions in his bi-monthly column regarding equipment and photography techniques in the field. He can be contacted via e-mail at this address: johnshaw@photosafaris.com. Due to the anticipated volume of inquiries John cannot answer questions individually, but he will cover a wide range of topics within each column. The new columns will come on-line May 1, July 1 and September 1. We look forward to hearing from you.




Joseph Van Os Photo Safaris, Inc. P.O. Box 655, Vashon Island, Washington USA 98070
Phone: (206) 463-5383   Fax: (206) 463-5484    Email: info@photosafaris.com
Copyright © 2008, Joseph Van Os Photo Safaris, Inc.